Granite vs. Marble vs. Quartz Kitchen Countertops: A Comprehensive Guide

Marble is a luxurious countertop material for any home.

Granite vs. Marble vs. Quartz Kitchen Countertops: A Comprehensive Guide

Nothing makes a kitchen stand out better than a gorgeous stone countertop. Choosing the right material is an important decision for any homeowner, but how do you choose between so many choices?

When it comes to kitchen countertops, three materials stand out: granite, marble, and quartz. Each has its own unique appeal, bringing an entirely different aesthetic to your kitchen. At Red Door Homes, we know just how important this decision is to you.

In this article, we’ll talk more about the pros and cons of each of these materials to help you make an informed decision for your kitchen.

Granite Countertops

Granite is a natural stone that is often a favorite when it comes to countertops. It has unique veining with specks of various materials that make each piece truly one-of-a-kind. The way it's formed gives it this unique appearance - igneous rock is made from cooled magma, giving granite a broad range of colors and patterns!

Some of the pros and cons of granite countertops include:


  • Durability: Granite is known for its hardness and resilience

  • Heat Resistance: Granite stands up well against hot pots and pans

  • Visual Appeal: Granite has a natural beauty that adds to any kitchen’s aesthetic


  • Porosity: Granite can absorb liquids if it isn’t properly sealed

  • Maintenance: This material needs regular sealing to maintain its functionality and beauty

  • Weight: Granite is one of the heaviest countertop materials, so you need a strong cabinet to hold it up

Maintenance and Care for Granite

Granite needs some more love and care than other stone countertops as it needs regular resealing. Without this care, your porous granite can become stained over time.

Cleaning, luckily, is easy to do. Simply use a soft cloth and soap to clean your countertops.

Marble Countertops

Marble is a metamorphic rock that is popular in homes of luxury. Its distinct veining and softer appearance compared to other stones have brought elegance to many kitchens. This stone is formed when limestone recrystallizes, forming the unique veins it's known for.

Some of the pros and cons of marble countertops include:


  • Aesthetic: Marble has a classic look perfect for both traditional and modern designs

  • Cool Surface: Marble is cool to the touch, which is a nice property for those who enjoy baking or pastry-making

  • Unique: No two marble slabs are exactly the same since they’re made naturally!


  • Porosity: Marble is even more prone to staining than granite is!

  • Scratches: Marble is a softer rock that can scratch and chip more easily than other stones

  • Maintenance: This building material needs regular sealing and more gentle cleansing than granite

Maintenance and Care of Marble Countertops

To care for marble countertops, gentle cleansers should be used. Because marble is so easily etched, acidic cleaners must be avoided and spills must be cleaned immediately. Regular sealing should also be done to protect the surface in the long run.

Quartz Countertops

Quartz countertops are engineered stone products. These countertops are around 90-95% natural quartz granules and 5-10% polymer resins.

Some pros and cons of quartz countertops include:


  • Non-porous: Quartz is resistant to staining and doesn’t need regular sealing

  • Low Maintenance: Easy to clean and maintain over long periods of time

  • Durable: Quartz is more resistant to scratches and chips than other materials


  • Heat Sensitive: Quartz isn’t as resistant to temperatures as other materials

  • UV Sensitive: If your kitchen has many windows, quartz can fade or discolor over time when exposed to sunlight

  • Artificial-looking: Because quartz is engineered, it isn’t as natural-looking as other stones

Quartz Countertop Maintenance

Quartz countertops are popular because they’re easy to clean and maintain compared to other countertop materials. These countertops only need mild soap and water to clean. However, it isn’t as heat-resistant, so you’ll want to use trivets for hot pots so you don’t burn your countertops.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to these different countertop materials, there are several factors to consider. From aesthetics to maintenance (and budget!), comparing all of the factors makes it much easier to make a final choice.

For those who appreciate natural beauty and don’t mind a bit of maintenance, granite may be your go-to. For those wanting a more elegant look they put effort into, marble is a good choice. And for those with a busy kitchen who want something durable and affordable, quartz is an excellent option.

Remember: each material has its own charm, and you really can’t go wrong with any of them. The choice depends on you and your lifestyle.

At Red Door Homes, we’ve seen each of these choices. We would love to make your dream home a reality, countertops and all. Reach out to us today to learn more about our Red Door Process and how we can help you.


How often do I need to seal my granite or marble countertop?

Ideally, you should seal our countertop at least once per year. However, you may have to do it more often depending on how often you use your countertops and the quality of your sealant.

Are quartz countertops stain-resistant?

Yes, quartz is highly resistant to stains.

How do costs compare between these countertop materials?

Typically, marble is considered the most expensive, followed by granite and then quartz as the least expensive.

Which of these options is the most eco-friendly?

Many consider quartz to be the most eco-friendly option due to its manufacturing process.

Can my countertops affect my home resale value?

Yes, high-quality countertops can definitely impact your home’s resale value. Typically, granite and marble are the most sought-after, but quartz can be a nice touch as well.

How do I prevent scratches and chips on my countertops?

Besides sealing, one easy way to prevent scratches and chips is by regularly using cutting boards. You should also avoid dropping heavy objects on the counter’s surface. You should especially be careful of this with more fragile materials like granite and marble.

Which material offers a greater design variety?

While all of these countertops are unique, quartz generally has a greater variety since it is manufactured.


We have worked with some amazing people

5 out of 5 stars

"Bryon was our project manager and we give major props to him for so many things! Always keeping the work space clean, keeping us in the loop every day, making sure we got everything we wanted, always being prompt and being so organized. Our home is everything we dreamed of and we couldn't be happier!! Thank you Red Door and Bryon for being so awesome!"

Heather M.
Google Review

5 out of 5 stars

"My husband and I are using Red Door to build our first home. So far, this has been an awesome experience. They're quick to get us answers to our questions, and have really listened to what we want to be able to guide us in the right direction on building our dream home within our budget."

Hunter B.
Google Review

5 out of 5 stars

"Red Door Homes recently completed a remodel for my family. They were top-notch! Michael B. and John H. are wonderful to work with. They met all deadlines, communicated every week, and even came in slightly under budget! Honest folks! Highly recommend!"

Google Review

5 out of 5 stars

"Red Door did a wonderful job building my new home. The salesman was able to take my design and modify the Aspen to match my layout. Every detail was met to my approval and expectations."

Titlow M.
Google Review

Get started on your dream home

We will only use this information to build you a custom quote and get you started on building your home. By submitting this form you agree to receive markting emails from our team at Red Door Homes. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply

What is the difference between a modular home and a stick-built home?

Modular homes are factory-built homes that are partially or entirely assembled in a factory and then brought onto the home site.

Stick-built homes are homes that have not been assembled in any way. These homes are constructed on-site around a stick frame and offer the option of complete customization. Many of our customers find our stick-build homes to be a quality, affordable alternative to modular homes in TN .

What is a construction loan?

A construction loan is the method of financing used when someone contracts to have a house built, as opposed to purchasing a completed home. Construction is financed in two loans: a construction loan for the period of construction, followed by a permanent loan, which pays off the construction loan.

Unlike mortgages, construction loans aren’t meant to be long term. Typically, a schedule is set up to enable funds to be withdrawn as needed to finance the various stages of construction. And, during the time your home is being built, you usually make interest-only payments on the loan.

I really like your homes.
What's the next step?

Set up an appointment with a sales consultant to help you choose your new home and discuss options you’d like included. You will receive a comprehensive list with pricing of all items that you want in your home and an estimate of the costs to prepare your lot.

Take the first step

Get in touch with us today to start your new home

Get started